• Skip to main content

JPNicols.com

Helping leaders make better decisions when the status quo feels safest

  • About
  • The Irrelevance Trap
  • Insights
  • Speaking
  • Contact

Bank Innovation

FinovateAsia Best of Show Winners

FA13BoSLogo.jpg

The second annual FinovateAsia 2013 wrapped up last week in Singapore, with 35 FinTech companies presenting their latest offerings. The audience-selected Best of Show winners are listed below in alphabetical order. (Thank you to Julie Schicktanz from the Finovate blog.)

_________________________________________________

BehaviosecLogo2013.jpg

BehavioSec, for its behavioral biometrics-based authentication method
Live blog post
IMG_3344.JPG
 
 
 _________________________________________________
 

INDGroupLogo.jpg

IND Group, for its Essence mobile banking app, with detailed financial management tools
Live blog post
IMG_3400.JPG

 

 _________________________________________________

 

KofaxLogo.jpg

Kofax, for its omni-channel solution that accelerates and enhances the underwriting process
Live blog post
IMG_3248.JPG

 

 _________________________________________________

 

YodleeLogo2012.jpg

Yodlee, for the international debut of TANDEM, an app that helps groups manage and discuss shared finances
Live blog post

IMG_3293.JPG

Check back on Finovate.com for the videos of all of the presenters.

 

Next up is FinovateEurope in London on February 11 & 12, 2014. I’ll be there live, plus the Bank Innovators Council also will be hosting a day-long Innovators Workshop in London immediately afterward on February 13 at Level 39, the largest FinTech accelerator in Europe.

 

——————————————————————

Notes on methodology (via Finovate):
1. Only audience members NOT associated with demoing companies were eligible to vote. Finovate employees did not vote.
2. Attendees were encouraged to note their favorites during each day. At the end of the last demo, they chose their three favorites.
3. The exact written instructions given to attendees: “Please rate (the companies) on the basis of demo quality and potential impact of the innovation demoed.”
4. The four companies appearing on the highest percentage of submitted ballots were named Best of Show.
5. Go here for a list of previous Best of Show winners.

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech

How Banks Can Compete in The Future

Compete in Future

Back in 1995 Michael Treacy and Fred Wiersema wrote a book called The Discipline of Market Leaders, and in it, they broke down the three critical strategic domains of any business– Customer Intimacy, Product Leadership and Operational Excellence.

They argued that companies couldn’t really dominate in more than one. None of these are exactly optional, but their research suggested that companies should focus on truly mastering just one of the domains and partnering or subcontracting with others in the areas where they couldn’t dominate.

Market Leaders

A few years later, John Hagel and Marc Singer from McKinsey & Company came to a similar conclusion in their Harvard Business Review piece Unbundling the Corporation. They even used very similar wording (Customer Relationship Management, Product Innovation and Infrastructure Management) to describe the domains.

Unbundling

The chart below combines the two concepts to show just how similar they are (Treacy and Wiersema are in blue text).

Market Leaders Unbundling CombinedThey both suggest kind of a Strengths Based Leadership approach for companies– improve your weaknesses enough to prevent failure, but the focus on your strengths to achieve greatness.

Implications for Financial Services

So, what kind of business is banking?

Some banks may indeed stay in the infrastructure management business, and even double down on the strategy. The basic machinery of banking actually works pretty well. Even in the fading hangover from the global financial crisis, trillions of financial transactions are made every year with astounding speed and accuracy.

I recently retweeted my recent post “From Transactions to Relationships: Innovation’s Next Horizon”, where I argued that banks are in the relationship management business; and I received a great response from Yann Ranchere, Finance Director of Anthemis Group, and publisher of the Tekfin blog, which is on my regular reading list.

In response to my tweet, Ranchere asked why becoming a dumb pipe was such a bad outcome, and he sent me a link to a post he had written in 2011 “Banking as a platform – what retail banking can learn from investment banking”.

I replied that I didn’t disagree; I just didn’t think that a lot of banks were making that choice consciously.

Screenshot 2013-10-28 14.40.50

 

Ranchere added that banks have infrastructure management in their DNA, (which is of course true), and I replied about the relative unattractiveness of utilities compared to consumer product/service companies, especially because the industry will only support so many utilities.

 

Screenshot 2013-10-28 14.47.17

 

Ranchere is absolutely correct. Banks do have this in their DNA, and some will be very successful at this. Think about State Street or The Bancorp, or even tiny CBW Bank in Weir, Kansas, the bank behind Moven. The problem is that the necessity to drive down costs and gain economies of scale mean that there will be only a few winners with this strategy.

Product Innovation

I would argue that very few banks to date have taken a product innovation approach, and I doubt that more than a handful are truly capable of being true innovation leaders. At least not in the same vein as Mint, PayPal, Square, Moven and other poster children for financial innovation.

This is not to say that banks and other financial institutions shouldn’t innovate. I spend a significant part of my life advocating, encouraging, preaching and cajoling bank leaders to place a higher priority on innovation. It’s just that most cannot expect to create and commercialize the majority of new innovative products and services from within their own four walls. They absolutely should be innovating early and often, but with a much broader perspective that is more inclusive of outside partners.

To effectively innovate new products and solutions, banks need to partner with FinTech companies, and even with each other. There is massive duplication of efforts in the industry.

Bankers are inherently risk-avoidant. At best they’re risk managers. Bankers have to be right 99% of the time in lending decisions, but innovation is about taking risks and failing and learning from those risks until you get it right.

The key is to fail fast and fail cheaply, and fail in an environment that is firewalled from impacting customers or shareholders.

How Banks Can Compete in the Future

Customer Relationship Management

I believe that more banks can win with a Customer Relationship Management strategy, but only if they actually run the business that way.

Most bankers would probably argue that they have always been in the customer relationship management business, but if we’re honest about the activities that get the most energy and attention in the industry, it really seems that most have taken an Infrastructure Management approach (I know, I know… the regulations rather reinforce that…).

Look at some of the descriptors of the Infrastructure Management strategy:

  • Battle for scale… Check.
  • A few big players dominate… Check.
  • Cost focused… Check.
  • Stresses standardization, predictability and efficiency…Check.

 

Unbundling Chart

 

A Customer Relationship Management approach is about economies of scope— expanding the share of wallet, in industry terms. Sure, we pay lip service to that, but it’s the customer-comes-first mentality where we usually drop the ball.

And that’s where the industry is most vulnerable to nimble start-ups that design everything around the customer experience.

 

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech, Practice Management

From Transactions to Relationships: Innovation’s Next Horizon

internet

There has never been a better time for innovation in financial services, yet most financial institutions struggle to build lasting, profitable relationships with their customer base. New ideas abound, yet actually implementing those new ideas, let alone realizing their financial promise remains elusive.

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way.                            

 – Charles Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities

Why?

One of the reasons is that so many of our industry’s innovations have been about improving transactions, not relationships. 

We can access our accounts 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. We can move money from point A to point B with speed and precision. We can access tax, investment and financial planning advice from software and online experts.

So what?

Sometimes we still can’t find what we’re looking for. Sometimes we don’t want to do it all ourselves. Sometimes we want a little help. Sometimes we want to just talk to a professional who will actually listen.

Customers today have many choices, and merely offering the usual menu of products and services will not create a compelling reason for them to choose your financial institution from the sea of similar offerings.

It’s not about your branch, or your ATM network or even your mobile banking platform. Those are just “dumb pipes”.

From Transactions to Relationships

But what if we spent just a little of our innovative energy on improving the relationships customers have with their financial providers?

What do we need to do to move from transactions to relationships? There are four imperatives:

  1. We have to shift our mindset from execution to diagnosis. In healthcare terms, it’s shifting from handing out prescriptions and treating symptoms to really understanding the underlying causes.
  2. We have to consciously build trust and loyalty with our customers. We have to think beyond the transaction, or even a successful series of transactions, and take the necessary steps to have our clients perceive– and believe— that we are worthy of their trust and loyalty.
  3. We have to move from product development– you know, that process where you launch a product that your team has been asking for, then point fingers internally when the financial results fail to meet expectations– to customer development. Customer development is an approach that makes sure that you are solving a problem or meeting a need that your paying customers actually care about.
  4. We have to engage the ecosystem. No product or service exists in a vacuum. Before we launch anything, we need to make sure that we are solving a problem our customers want solved, we have to understand the role our internal and external partners play in the process and we have to know what the value chain looks like and where we fit in. We also want to make sure we avoid any co-innovation risk and adoption risk along the way.

It’s not rocket science, but it is a big change from the way most financial institutions do business. If we can do those things well, we can begin to create value in our relationships and we can innovate new paths to profitable growth.

 

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech

Bank Innovators Council Launch Party

Last week during Finovate Fall 2013 we launched the Bank Innovators Council. More than 75 bank innovators, entrepreneurs, CEOs, bloggers and industry analysts joined us on a Manhattan rooftop to celebrate the launch of the first organization designed by bank innovators for bank innovators.

We are proud to be creating a platform to bank innovators do together what they can’t do alone. Join us at BankInnovatorsCouncil.org

Bank Innovators Council LinkedIn Group

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech

Finovate Fall 2013 Best of Show Winners

FF2013-BestofShow

Finovate Fall 2013 wrapped up a whirlwind two days of FinTech innovation in New York on September 10 and 11. Eight of the 69 presenting companies were voted Best of Show by those in attendance.

Five of those eight winners had direct or indirect applicability for the investing/financial planning/wealth management space (LearnVest, MoneyDesktop, Motif, TipRanks and Yodlee).

Rising Above a Difficult Venue

This year’s venue at the Manhattan Center (which includes the historic Hammerstein Ballroom) was not the best for this kind of show. Finovate  is really two simultaneous events– the eight sets of back to back to back rapid-fire 7-mintue demos (no slides or Q&A), and the longer one-on-one interactions with the presenters at each of their booths for those who want to learn more and/or make connections. Past venues provided sufficient separation between the stage and the presenter booths to allow both to co-exist. That was not the case this year, and unfortunately both parts suffered a little.

Beyond rows of chairs close to the stage, better seats with tables were placed around the two balconies, with remote viewing via video screens also available on the 7th floor and its balcony (plus a press room in the basement) . This split up the crowd a quite a bit and did make it more difficult for the ongoing conversations and networking that are so valuable at a show like this. There were also a few audio glitches that detracted, but the WiFi was much better than last year at Javits Center.

Finovate_Fall_2013_1

Still,  it was great to see all of the newest innovations, meet the innovators behind them and catch up with my growing list of friends at these must-attend events.

RatPack

Bank Innovators Council

(In a semi-related note, we held the launch party for the new Bank Innovators Council on the middle night of Finovate. More than 75 bankers, partners and thought leaders joined us on a Manhattan rooftop to kick off this new organization designed specifically to help bankers innovate together in ways they cannot do alone. More on this in a future post)

Screen Shot 2013-09-12 at 3.53.10 PM

Finovate Fall 2013 Best of Show Winners

(in alphabetical order):

 

InteractionsLogo.jpg

Interactions, for its voice-based virtual assistant technology

Interactions.jpg
______________________________________________________

LearnVEstlogo.jpg

LearnVest, for its iPad app and Workplace Solutions Center
LearnVest.jpg
______________________________________________________

mBankAccenturelogo.jpg

mBank & Accenture,  for their Bank 3.0 online platform
mBank.jpg
______________________________________________________
MitekLogo13.jpg
Mitek for its Mobile Photo Account Opening solution
MitekFFPic.jpg
______________________________________________________
MoneyDesktopLogoNew.jpg
MoneyDesktop, for its GuideMe solution
MDpic.jpg
______________________________________________________
motiflogo.jpg
Motif for its platform that lets you invest in ideas in one click
HardeeepIMG.jpeg
______________________________________________________
TipRanks, cloud-based accountability engine for investors
TipRanksLogo.jpg
tipranks.jpg
______________________________________________________
YodleeLogo2012.jpg
Yodlee, for its debut of TANDEM that helps groups manage and discuss shared finances
yodleeFFimg.jpg

 

Congratulations to all of the Finovate Fall 2013 Best of Show winners, all of whom are very deserving of this honor.

I also send an extra personal congratulations to my friends at MoneyDesktop and Yodlee, whom I have had the pleasure of getting to know and work with over the past year. I look forward to our future collaboration.

Read the entire story on finovate.com, where you will also soon be able to see videos of all 69 presentations from Finovate Fall 2013.

 

 

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech

Bankers of the World, Unite! (and Innovate!)

BIC_square_logo

Innovating in banks is hard.

It’s even harder doing it alone.

FinTech entrepreneurs have incubators, accelerators, VCs and hackathons to support and encourage innovation, but banks are on their own.

Until now.

Today I am excited to introduce the launch of the Bank Innovators Council, along with my co-founder, former BBVA Compass executive and fellow innovator Will Trout.

We know that most banks are not able to afford their own innovation labs and teams.

But we also know they can’t afford not to innovate.

The Bank Innovators Council is primarily designed for financial institutions without fully developed innovation capabilities. The council will provide opportunities for members to pool their resources to develop and test new ideas outside of the day-to-day demands of their existing businesses, in ways they could not do alone. We will also curate outside research and technology and help bank innovators create, test and launch new ideas.

Read today’s full press release.

Launch Party in New York during Finovate Fall

We are hosting a launch party for the Bank Innovators Council on September 10, 2013 in New York, coinciding with the Finovate Conference September 10-11, where 60 FinTech companies will demo their latest technology to an expected crowd of 1,000 bankers, investors, analysts and members of the media.

Limited spots remain for the launch event, and requests to attend can be made here.

Screen Shot 2013-08-22 at 12.40.29 PM

 

Filed Under: Bank Innovation

Too Small to Fail: The Partnership Driven Nature of FinTech Startups

Too small to fail: The partnership-driven nature of fintech startups (via Pando Daily)

By Houston Frost On May 22, 2013In the last quarter-century or so that has made up the digital revolution, one universal axiom has held true: evolve or die. Record labels were too busy suing pirates in the 1990s to adapt their business model to the digital world, newspapers were consigned to the recycle…


[Read more…] about Too Small to Fail: The Partnership Driven Nature of FinTech Startups

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech

What About the Overbanked?

I spent a great couple of days in San Francisco this week hearing from 72 FinTech companies at Finovate, stay tuned for my unique recap and thoughts from the largest Finovate ever.

As usual, there were several companies focused on improving access and service to the so-called underbanked– those who are priced out of traditional banking services, and those who simply opt out. This is a large market– several markets actually, and providing services people want and need at an affordable price is always good business.

But what about the Overbanked?

I’m talking about affluent and high net worth customers. Not because they don’t have sufficient access or because they are priced out of any markets. In fact, it’s just the opposite. Affluent customers have plenty of choices. Maybe too many. It is a market niche most financial institutions should be pursuing, but it’s hard to stand out to affluent customers.

Marketers hoping to reach the affluent need to tailor their offerings to be relevant. Messages about daily cash flow budgeting, for instance, can be powerful for the mass market and the underbanked. Every dollar matters and the timing of every dollar matters. It is worth spending time on activities that will save money by avoiding late fees and overdraft fees, for instance.

For many (though not all) affluent customers, it’s the other way around– they will often willingly spend additional money in order to save time. They will also spend money on unique experiences, as I have written about before.

(See Reimagining Bank Product Design in the Experience Economy)

Filed Under: Bank Innovation, FinTech, Practice Management

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Go to Next Page »
  • Contact
  • Speaker One-Sheet
  • Media Kit
  • Podcast
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Alloy Labs

Copyright © 2026 · Infinity Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...